The five players above Rodgers were Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, J.J Watt, Calvin Johnson, and Adrian Peterson. I can understand Peterson, but why Calvin Johnson and the rest of them? The Lions aren't that good so it doesn't really matter how good one guy is, and the other three simply aren't as talented as Rodgers. Rodgers is much more consistent than those other two QBs on this list. When he loses, it's always the defense's fault.